19 November 2026

Shareholder disputes and bad leaver clauses: what goes wrong and how do you prevent it?

Stelt u zich eens voor: u werkt al jaren met dezelfde zelfstandige. Hij stuurt facturen, factureert btw en heeft een eigen kvk-nummer. Toch krijgt u in 2026 ineens vragen van de Belastingdienst over de aard van uw samenwerking. Hoe heeft het zo ver kunnen komen?

This blog is intended for entrepreneurs who hold shares in a private limited company (BV) together with others and who are also active in it as a director or managing director. In other words, you are not only an investor, but also a working partner. This combination of roles is very common in SMEs, but it also creates specific risks that are often not properly covered in a standard shareholders’ agreement.

So imagine this: you run a BV together with one or two other entrepreneurs. You are not only a shareholder, but also a working director. You have a shareholders’ agreement, because that seemed sensible. But one day the partnership breaks down, you are dismissed as a director and you discover that you also have to transfer your shares, at a price of zero euros. This is not an imaginary scenario. It is exactly what happened in two recent court cases that show how far-reaching the consequences can be if a shareholders’ agreement has not been properly worked out.

In this blog, I therefore discuss the most important lessons from those cases, translated into concrete advice for entrepreneurs who work together in a BV as both shareholder and director. Because that is precisely where it becomes complicated, and risky, for you as an entrepreneur.

What is the difference between a good leaver and a bad leaver?

Before we discuss the lessons from case law, a brief explanation of the two key concepts.

A good leaver is someone who leaves the BV for a reason that is not their fault: illness, death, incapacity for work or a departure that everyone agrees on. As a rule, a good leaver receives a fair price for their shares, usually the market value.

A bad leaver is someone who leaves under circumstances that are regarded as misconduct or breach of contract: they have broken the rules, leave against the will of the others, or (and this is the dangerous part) they are dismissed as a director by their fellow shareholders and thereby automatically qualify as a bad leaver. A bad leaver must transfer their shares, often for a fraction of the actual value or even for the nominal value: sometimes only a few hundred euros instead of hundreds of thousands.

Lesson 1: Dismissal as a director automatically triggers bad leaver status

A ruling by the District Court of The Hague in December 2025 centred on a minority shareholder who was also a director of the BV. The majority shareholder decided to dismiss her as statutory director through the general meeting. The result: the shareholders’ agreement automatically triggered the obligation to offer her shares under the bad leaver provision.

What makes this situation treacherous is that, with a simple meeting resolution, a majority shareholder can set two consequences in motion at the same time: the dismissal of the director and the loss of their shares. That mechanism gives the majority an enormous position of power over the minority. In this case, the shares were valued at nil, while the person concerned had paid a total of EUR 408,333 for them.

Practical tips on dismissal and leaver status:

  • Stipulate in the shareholders’ agreement that dismissal as a director does not automatically result in a bad leaver situation; make a clear distinction between dismissal under company law and the contractual consequences for the shares.
  • Set out which specific circumstances do justify a bad leaver classification (think of fraud, breach of non-compete clauses or embezzlement), so that a dismissal for business-economic reasons or an ordinary difference of opinion has different consequences.
  • Include a dispute resolution clause: the fact that the majority can always dismiss makes protection mechanisms for the minority shareholder essential.

Lesson 2: A verbal agreement is legally worthless

Another problem played a role in the same case. The dismissed director argued that the dismissal was intended to be temporary (a practical measure to get through the winter period and apply for benefits) and that verbal agreements had been made that this would not result in a bad leaver situation. The court did not accept this, because the temporary nature was not apparent anywhere from the dismissal resolution. Moreover, she had drafted the resolution herself, which the court gave extra weight.

That is an extremely high bar: verbal agreements, email correspondence referring to a “split” and a subjective perception of the situation are insufficient if the dismissal resolution itself has been drafted clearly and without nuance.

Practical tips on recording agreements in writing:

  • Record every deviation from the shareholders’ agreement in writing, preferably in a side letter or supplementary agreement signed by all parties.
  • As a director or minority shareholder, never draft a dismissal resolution without explicitly stating all reservations and agreements in it; check every document for its contractual consequences before signing.
  • Always check, before agreeing to a resolution under company law, what the contractual consequences are under the shareholders’ agreement. A “friendly” dismissal can cost you your entire shareholding.

Lesson 3: Misconduct as a director can lead to a transfer at nominal value

A ruling by the District Court of Noord-Holland in March 2026 concerned a case in which a director, who was also a registered accountant, had structurally disadvantaged her fellow shareholders. For years she received considerably higher management fees than her fellow shareholders, without any written basis. In addition, the company granted her an interest-free loan of around 40% of the total balance sheet value, without written documentation or the consent of the other shareholders. Finally, she unilaterally extended a lease between the BV (as tenant) and herself privately (as landlord) by five years, causing the BV to take on more than EUR 200,000 in additional obligations.

The court ruled that this constituted a so-called “material breach” of the shareholders’ agreement. The result: she had to transfer her shares to her fellow shareholders at nominal value, a fraction of the actual market value.

Practical tips on share valuation and bad leaver sanctions:

  • Define in concrete terms in the shareholders’ agreement what a “material breach” is, and link a differentiated price (a sliding scale) to the seriousness of the breach, so that the sanction is proportionate to the offence. A transfer at nominal value for minor misconduct is disproportionate; for serious misconduct it may stand.
  • As a fellow shareholder, record all financial arrangements in writing: management fees, loans, leases and other transactions between a shareholder and the BV must always be approved by the other shareholders and recorded in writing.
  • Be aware that a court can assess a bad leaver price against the standards of “reasonableness and fairness”: an excessively heavy sanction can be mitigated, but only if the affected shareholder asks the court to do so. This is something that is often forgotten.

Lesson 4: Conflicts of interest are a time bomb under the partnership

Both cases show that conflicts of interest between shareholder-directors are the main source of escalation. A director who is also a shareholder can take decisions that serve their own interests at the expense of the BV and their fellow shareholders. The law (Article 2:239 of the Dutch Civil Code) prohibits a director with a conflict of interest from taking part in decision-making, but in practice this is monitored too little.

Practical tips on conflicts of interest and governance:

  • Include a procedure in the shareholders’ agreement for identifying and reporting conflicts of interest: who decides on this, how is it minuted, and which decisions require unanimity or the approval of a third party?
  • Set up a list of decisions requiring approval (“reserved matters”): determine which decisions (such as taking out loans, adjusting management fees or extending leases) require the explicit written consent of all shareholders.
  • Carry out an annual governance review: discuss the state of affairs with your fellow shareholders and record even small deviations from existing agreements.

Lesson 5: Escalation routes are essential, but often missing

In both cases there was no effective escalation structure: problems that could have been identified earlier ended up in court proceedings. Shareholder disputes settled through the courts usually take years and tens of thousands of euros in legal costs, while the relationship is damaged beyond repair in the meantime.

Practical tips on disputes and escalation:

  • Include a mandatory mediation step in the shareholders’ agreement before the parties may go to court. This prevents a conflict that could be de-escalated from immediately becoming a legal battle.
  • Arrange a “deadlock” procedure: what happens if the shareholders cannot reach agreement among themselves? Think of a Texas shoot-out clause (in which one party makes an offer that the other party can accept or reverse) or a mandatory exit procedure based on an independent valuation.
  • Appoint an independent chair or supervisory director for cases in which the relationships between shareholder-directors are too close to decide objectively.

Conclusion: three concrete takeaways

  1. Do not automatically link dismissal to bad leaver status. Make sure your shareholders’ agreement clearly states in which cases dismissal as a director does and does not lead to bad leaver status. A majority that can force a bad leaver situation without limits is an unacceptable risk for any minority shareholder.
  2. Differentiate the sanction and record everything in writing. A bad leaver provision that always leads to a transfer at nominal value is vulnerable to judicial review and unfair in the case of minor breaches. Link the seriousness of the breach to the size of the discount, and record every deviation from existing agreements in writing, however informal the situation may seem.
  3. Build in escalation structures before you need them. A shareholders’ agreement without a dispute resolution clause, mediation step or deadlock procedure forces the parties towards the courts at the very first conflict. That is expensive, slow and destructive for the company. The core message remains simple: arrange it properly before relationships deteriorate, because after that it is too late.

Join our breakfast session on 3 December 2026

Would you like to know how to set up your shareholders’ agreement so that shareholder disputes are prevented rather than fought out? On Thursday 3 December 2026, The Legal Company is organising a free breakfast session on exactly this theme. Register here (only a limited number of places available): shareholder disputes and preventing escalation.

Feel free to contact us to register or for more information. We, the corporate lawyers of The Legal Company, are happy to support you.

Blog by our corporate lawyer Hella Vercammen LL.M.

 

De afgelopen jaren stonden in het teken van de Wet VBAR, het wetsvoorstel dat een einde moest maken aan onduidelijkheid over de zzp’er. Het kabinet heeft delen van dat voorstel inmiddels geschrapt. Op het eerste gezicht is dat goed nieuws: minder regels, minder administratieve last. Maar in de praktijk blijven dezelfde toetsen overeind.

“De inhoud van de samenwerking is leidend, niet wat er op papier staat.”

De Belastingdienst handhaaft sinds 1 januari 2025 weer actief op schijnzelfstandigheid. En recente uitspraken van de Hoge Raad bevestigen dat rechters strikt toetsen of er sprake is van ondergeschiktheid en gezagsverhouding.

Voor uw praktijk betekent dit drie dingen. Een: leg de samenwerking duidelijk vast, met aandacht voor de inhoud. Twee: voorkom dat een zzp’er feitelijk werkt als werknemer. Drie: wees voorbereid op een controle, en weet hoe u de relatie kunt herzien als dat moet.

Heeft u vragen over uw concrete situatie? Wij sparren dagelijks met opdrachtgevers over hun zzp-relaties. Vraag een offerte op of bekijk onze Legal Safe abonnementen.

Hella Vercammen LL.M.
Bente Brouwer LL.M.
Niels Terlouw LL.M.
Puck de Jong LL.M.
Celine Sup LL.M.

Read more