The Self-Employed Persons Act (Zelfstandigenwet) is meant to provide clarity on when someone can work as a self-employed person. But whether the act will actually do so remains to be seen. The public internet consultation has in any case produced strong criticism: of the 1,172 responses, no less than 85% are negative about the bill in its current form.
Although the Dutch government is working on an alternative to the current assessment of working relationships, there is little reason for clients to sit back in the meantime. Enforcement against false self-employment continues, and as of 1 January 2027 the soft landing will lapse in its entirety.
Much criticism of how the Self-Employed Persons Act is worked out
The bill aims to introduce two tests: the self-employment test and the working relationship test. Anyone who meets both tests qualifies for a so-called ‘safe harbour’. This should make it clear in advance that there is independent entrepreneurship and not an employment contract.
That starting point enjoys broad support. How it has been worked out, however, turns out to be a lot less popular. The analysis by ZiPconomy shows that 85% of respondents are negative or very negative about the bill. Notably, 81% of respondents who explicitly support the purpose of the act are also critical of the proposed elaboration.
The biggest stumbling block is the requirement that a self-employed person must have had at least three clients within two years. No less than 74% of respondents object to this. This requirement is seen as particularly problematic in the ICT sector and in interim and advisory work. After all, long-term assignments with a single client are the rule rather than the exception there. The mandatory spending on provisions and the proposed obligation to achieve a result also raise questions.
It is not only self-employed people who are critical. Trade associations, intermediaries and clients also point to practical objections. For example, there is a fear that in practice the ‘safe harbour’ will in fact become a new hiring requirement, leaving self-employed people who do not meet all the criteria out in the cold. There is also uncertainty about the position of intermediaries and the question of who should be regarded as the client in that case.
Minister Aartsen has since promised to amend the proposal if the resistance is too great. It should therefore be clear that the current text is not yet the final destination.
The Self-Employed Persons Act is still a thing of the future
Clients should realise, however, that the act will not come into force for the time being. After the consultation responses have been processed, the proposal still has to be worked out further, sent to the Council of State for advice and then dealt with by both Houses of Parliament. Moreover, the intended date of entry into force is not until 1 January 2028.
Until then, the existing legal frameworks and case law therefore remain decisive in assessing working relationships. The holistic test from the Supreme Court’s Deliveroo judgment remains the starting point. Not one individual criterion, but all relevant circumstances of the case are assessed in conjunction when answering the question of whether there is false self-employment.
No more soft landing from 1 January 2027
For clients, the most urgent development right now is not the Self-Employed Persons Act, but the lapse of the soft landing as of 1 January 2027. In 2025 and 2026, a partial soft landing still applied, under which in principle no default penalties were imposed, but as of 1 January 2027 this concession will lapse. During the soft landing, the Dutch Tax Administration also usually confined itself to company visits in which clients were often given a warning first. From 2027, however, the Tax Administration will immediately proceed to a books audit.
What can clients already do now?
We advise companies to use the coming period for a critical review of their current pool of freelancers. Map out which self-employed people are hired, what work they do and under what circumstances they do it. Pay particular attention to long-term partnerships, self-employed people who are structurally part of the organisation, and situations in which the client largely determines how, where and when the work is carried out. Then assess whether the existing agreements and the actual way of working still correspond with each other. Where possible, adjustments can be made to both the contractual arrangements and day-to-day practice.
The corporate lawyers of The Legal Company have extensive experience in assessing and structuring working relationships and in limiting the legal risks surrounding the hiring of self-employed people. We can support you in reviewing your existing freelance contracts, identifying risks and, where necessary, adjusting your agreements and way of working. Feel free to contact us at info@thelegalcompany.nl or 020-3450152.
Blog by our corporate lawyer Niels Terlouw LL.M.