A mechanic felt he was entitled to the higher wages of the company where he worked for a long time. The subdistrict court ruled that his own employer remained in charge and rejected that claim. A ruling that is all the more topical for the many SMEs that hire out or hire in staff, now that the admission requirement under the WTTA is approaching.
What happened?
From July 2022 to August 2024, a mechanic was employed by a company that repairs and maintains trains, trams and metros. The Collective Labour Agreement for the Technical Installation Sector applied to his employment contract. During his employment, he was deployed for a large number of days at another company, which was carrying out large-scale train maintenance on behalf of NS (Dutch Railways) and needed extra mechanics for that job. He was also deployed on various other projects of his own employer. When the employment ended, the mechanic took the position that he had been paid too little all that time, and he brought the matter before the subdistrict court.
What was the dispute about?
The main claim was based on the WAADI (the Dutch Placement of Personnel by Intermediaries Act). According to him, his employer had “made him available” to the other company, and he was therefore entitled to at least the same terms of employment as the permanent employees there, in this case the higher wages under the Metalektro collective labour agreement. After all, Article 8(1) of the WAADI provides that a worker who has been made available is entitled to at least the same pay as employees in the same or equivalent positions employed by the company where the worker has been placed. On that basis, the mechanic claimed just over € 9,500 gross in wage differences, plus the statutory increase, interest and collection costs. In addition, he claimed just over € 5,000 gross in unpaid travel hours, in case the WAADI did not apply.
The statutory criterion: who exercises direction and supervision?
The WAADI defines “making workers available” as making workers available to another party in return for payment, to perform work under that party’s supervision and direction, other than under an employment contract concluded with that party. That criterion is therefore the core: only if actual direction and supervision lie with the hirer is there a placement within the meaning of the act, with the result that the employee can claim the hirer’s terms of employment. If direction still lies with the formal employer, it is more likely to be (sub)contracting of work, and the WAADI does not apply.
This standard has also been elaborated by the Supreme Court in the context of the Temporary Agency Work Directive: what is decisive is whether the employee works for a certain period for and under the direction of the labour provider, and is then made available by the labour provider to a hiring company in order to work there under the supervision and direction of that hirer.[1] This is not about a qualification on paper, but about the actual situation: who determines the roster, who arranges leave and sickness, who gives instructions, and who provides the clothing and tools.
What did the subdistrict court decide in this case?
The subdistrict court of the District Court of Gelderland rejected the main claim, because the criterion of direction and supervision by the hiring company was not met. In fact, according to the court, this was subcontracting: his own employer supplied mechanics for a specific assignment, but remained the material employer. The following circumstances were decisive:
The mechanic reported his leave and sickness to his own employer and also received his roster from that employer. The fact that, because he worked at one client for so long, he also reported leave and sickness there did not, according to the court, mean that he was obliged to do so. Furthermore, he was also deployed on other projects of his own employer, which confirmed that the planning of his deployment lay with the employer. In addition, he wore his employer’s clothing, used basic tools from that employer and drove a company car provided by the employer. The fact that he may have received instructions on site and used specific tools from the other company was not enough to lead to a different conclusion.
Because the main claim failed on this point, the alternative claim for travel hours came into view. Because that claim had only been submitted shortly before the hearing, the proceedings were adjourned on that point so that the employer could first respond in writing.
Relevance for the WTTA: why this is especially important right now
In practice, many companies turn out not to know for certain whether or not they are making workers available. That uncertainty is exactly what this ruling is about: whether there is a placement depends on actual direction and supervision, and not on what the parties call their cooperation.
Under the WTTA, that qualification is not only a question of wage law, but also one of licensing: only those who actually make workers available must register for the transitional arrangement and then apply for admission or, where applicable, an exemption. Those who register unnecessarily burden themselves with administrative and financial obligations for no reason. Those who wrongly fail to register because the cooperation was regarded as subcontracting run the risk that a court will still establish a placement afterwards, with the enforcement risks of a missing admission as a result. That is precisely why the direction and supervision test is so important.
Not every situation is equally clear. In mixed structures, long-term project deployment or changing authority to give instructions, the outcome may be different, while an incorrect qualification now entails extra risks because of the admission requirement under the WTTA. With the deadline for the transitional arrangement in sight, it is wise, if in doubt, to err on the side of caution and have us check your form of cooperation in good time.
If you would like to find out more about what the WTTA entails, the admission requirement and the transitional arrangement, we are happy to refer you to our earlier blog on this subject for a refresher.
Feel free to contact us at info@thelegalcompany.nl or 020-3450152.
[1] Supreme Court, 20 May 2025, ECLI:NL:HR:2022:751
Blog by our corporate lawyer Bente Brouwer LL.M.