19 November 2026

A shareholder dispute resolution clause: a paper tiger?

Stelt u zich eens voor: u werkt al jaren met dezelfde zelfstandige. Hij stuurt facturen, factureert btw en heeft een eigen kvk-nummer. Toch krijgt u in 2026 ineens vragen van de Belastingdienst over de aard van uw samenwerking. Hoe heeft het zo ver kunnen komen?

A dispute resolution clause on paper, but no solution in practice: what if shareholders end up opposing each other?

A company that is doing well, two shareholders who each hold 50%, and a difference of opinion about the future direction. It sounds like a familiar situation for entrepreneurs. But what happens if the shareholders can no longer reach agreement and important decisions are blocked as a result? A recent ruling by the District Court of Amsterdam shows that a contractually agreed dispute resolution clause is not always enough to break such a deadlock.

A difference of opinion about the future

In the case brought before the District Court of Amsterdam, two shareholders of PartnerBoost B.V. were opposing each other. Both indirectly held 50% of the shares and were also directors. The company focused on improving partnerships between Microsoft and other businesses and was doing well.

In October 2025, a plan arose to expand the activities to Germany. There was said to be sufficient market demand there, and a suitable candidate had also been found to set up the German operations. Initially, both shareholders explored the options together. In the end, however, one of them was not in favour of the expansion: in her view, the company first had to focus on further growth in the Netherlands, where the management foundation was not yet stable enough.

The other shareholder, by contrast, saw an important commercial opportunity that should not be left unused. Because of the 50/50 ratio, important decisions could not be taken without the consent of both shareholders. A deadlock was the result.

The dispute resolution clause offers no way out

To prevent situations like this, the parties had included a so-called deadlock clause in their shareholders’ agreement. In the event of a deadlock, a new general meeting first had to be convened. If no agreement was reached there either, the parties had to try to resolve the dispute through mediation. For disputes that remained after that, the competent court in Amsterdam was designated.

The shareholder in favour of expansion to Germany argued that she had gone through these steps. Two general meetings had since taken place, but no agreement had been reached. The other shareholder then refused to cooperate in mediation.

The shareholder arguing for expansion then went to the preliminary relief judge. Among other things, she demanded that the other shareholder be ordered to cooperate in the expansion to Germany, or alternatively that she be given permission to carry out similar activities outside the joint company.

The preliminary relief judge does not intervene

The preliminary relief judge rejected the claims. Although there was a fundamental difference of opinion, the judge saw insufficient reason to intervene in the company’s policy. Both shareholders had substantiated their positions with reasons and had not reached their convictions lightly.

According to the preliminary relief judge, it is in principle up to the board (with the approval of the general meeting) to decide whether commercial opportunities should be pursued. The fact that expansion to Germany might lead to profitable growth was insufficient to justify judicial intervention and to force the reluctant director and shareholder to take that decision after all. After all, the continuity of the company was not at risk.

The judge did emphasise that the reluctant director and shareholder could be expected to start mediation in the short term. She was contractually obliged to do so. However, the judge could not oblige her to actually take part in mediation, because voluntariness is a basic principle of mediation.

Could the Enterprise Chamber have offered a solution?

This is exactly where the ruling becomes interesting. In their shareholders’ agreement, the parties had opted for the ordinary court in Amsterdam. The preliminary relief judge takes a restrained approach to disputes about the commercial direction of a company. That is different at the Enterprise Chamber of the Amsterdam Court of Appeal, which has broad powers within inquiry proceedings to intervene in the relationships within a company. For example, it can temporarily suspend a director or appoint a temporary director to break a deadlock.

That does not mean, incidentally, that the Enterprise Chamber would automatically have intervened in this situation to force a director and shareholder to vote in favour. For that, there must be, among other things, a state of affairs within the legal entity that makes immediate measures necessary. In my view, merely missing out on a potentially profitable investment opportunity would not have been sufficient for that. So this route does not guarantee that a deadlock will be broken either. Sometimes you also simply have to accept that if one director/shareholder does not want any new ventures, the other has to resign themselves to that. Certainly if this does not cause any losses, and does not cause the company to lose its right to exist or prevent it from continuing.

What else can entrepreneurs learn from this?

This ruling also shows that it is not enough to simply include a dispute resolution clause in a shareholders’ agreement. Entrepreneurs must also consider which body should ultimately rule on a dispute, and what options that body has to actually break a deadlock.

A clause that only provides for consultation, mediation and recourse to the ordinary court does not always offer sufficient certainty. It is therefore advisable to work out different scenarios. The articles of association and the shareholders’ agreement must also be properly aligned, especially in the case of a 50/50 ratio.

Prevention is better than litigation

A difference of opinion between shareholders need not be a problem. It does become one when a company can no longer move forward because of it. That is precisely why it is important to make clear agreements in advance about decision-making and the possibility of breaking a deadlock.

The corporate lawyers of The Legal Company are happy to help you draw up and review shareholders’ agreements and articles of association. In doing so, we look not only at the agreements during a successful partnership, but especially at the situation in which shareholders no longer agree with each other. Feel free to contact us at info@thelegalcompany.nl or 020-3450152.

Blog by our corporate lawyer Niels Terlouw LL.M.

 

De afgelopen jaren stonden in het teken van de Wet VBAR, het wetsvoorstel dat een einde moest maken aan onduidelijkheid over de zzp’er. Het kabinet heeft delen van dat voorstel inmiddels geschrapt. Op het eerste gezicht is dat goed nieuws: minder regels, minder administratieve last. Maar in de praktijk blijven dezelfde toetsen overeind.

“De inhoud van de samenwerking is leidend, niet wat er op papier staat.”

De Belastingdienst handhaaft sinds 1 januari 2025 weer actief op schijnzelfstandigheid. En recente uitspraken van de Hoge Raad bevestigen dat rechters strikt toetsen of er sprake is van ondergeschiktheid en gezagsverhouding.

Voor uw praktijk betekent dit drie dingen. Een: leg de samenwerking duidelijk vast, met aandacht voor de inhoud. Twee: voorkom dat een zzp’er feitelijk werkt als werknemer. Drie: wees voorbereid op een controle, en weet hoe u de relatie kunt herzien als dat moet.

Heeft u vragen over uw concrete situatie? Wij sparren dagelijks met opdrachtgevers over hun zzp-relaties. Vraag een offerte op of bekijk onze Legal Safe abonnementen.

Hella Vercammen LL.M.
Bente Brouwer LL.M.
Niels Terlouw LL.M.
Puck de Jong LL.M.
Celine Sup LL.M.

Read more