3 January 2023

Self-employed workers in the cleaning sector: wolf (in sheep’s clothing) or Little Red Riding Hood?

Stelt u zich eens voor: u werkt al jaren met dezelfde zelfstandige. Hij stuurt facturen, factureert btw en heeft een eigen kvk-nummer. Toch krijgt u in 2026 ineens vragen van de Belastingdienst over de aard van uw samenwerking. Hoe heeft het zo ver kunnen komen?

Cleaning companies today work a great deal with self-employed subcontractors because of the tight labour market. More and more employees are also choosing to terminate their permanent employment in order to register as self-employed with the Chamber of Commerce. The employer they used to work for as an employee then, out of necessity, re-engages that former employee as a self-employed worker. How safe is that, really? Especially in the tight economic times still to come, and with the government’s upcoming plans?

Broadly speaking, there are two kinds of risk involved in working with self-employed workers: tax risks and legal risks. To limit both the tax and the legal risks, cleaning entrepreneurs need to keep a close eye on their working methods and contractual arrangements, in particular to prevent false self-employment.

Tax risk

As the hiring client, you run the risk of the Tax Authority ruling that there is false self-employment between your company and the self-employed cleaners, and that work is therefore actually being performed under employment. The result is a retrospective assessment of payroll tax, national insurance contributions, employee insurance contributions and the Health Insurance Act contribution, potentially with a fine. However, enforcement has been suspended by the tax authorities. Only bad-faith clients who work with falsely self-employed persons (note: so really (deemed) employment relationships) still run enforcement risks.

Bad faith = deliberately acting, knowing or ought to have known that someone is in a (deemed) employment relationship.

This enforcement risk has to date been negligible. There have so far only been two warnings and one correction to a tax return. The government will of course change this, but that will still take some time. Read more about that below.

Employment-law risk

The second and currently the greatest risk is that the self-employed worker, in the event of illness, a workplace accident, or after you unilaterally terminate the engagement (due to a decrease in assignments), argues that there was in fact an employment contract all along (false self-employment). In that way, the self-employed worker can still claim the benefits of an employment contract, dismissal protection, and the statutory severance payments.

Other employment-law claims can relate to:

  • Continued payment of wages (during illness or absence of work);
  • Holiday allowance and days;
  • The obligation to continue paying wages and to reintegrate in the event of illness;
  • Pension (industry pension fund (Bpf) or participation in company pension);
  • CAO allowances and other entitlements;
  • Entitlements under the employer’s internal arrangements.

The chance that this self-employed worker will succeed in this within the cleaning sector, and certainly in the case where this person was previously employed, is considerable. This is because there is usually no changed working arrangement, and the self-employed worker actually (still) works, or has continued to work, under your “authority”. Hence the question of whether the self-employed worker will turn out to have been a wolf in sheep’s clothing in leaner economic times, or will still turn out to have been a helpful Little Red Riding Hood after all.

Now, that would not necessarily be a bad thing in itself, if a self-employed worker claims an employment relationship while you are still looking for new permanent staff. Terminating the engagement of self-employed workers can therefore also be a way to force those self-employed workers back into employment. However, do not wait too long with that, and do it while you still have plenty of work. After all, if you terminate the engagement because you genuinely have too little work, then you do not want any extra staff at all, and therefore no wolf in sheep’s clothing knocking on your door either.

Self-employment government plans in 2023

On 1 June 2022, the Social and Economic Council (SER) (an advisory body made up of employers, trade unions and independent “crown members”) presented its advice to the government on the labour market, including stricter rules for self-employed workers.

Following that advice, the government drew up a Letter on the Main Lines of the Labour Market for 2023 and beyond on 5 July 2022, in which it sets out its plans, including for self-employed workers.

Concretely, those plans amount to the following:

  1. Working towards a more level playing field for contract forms with respect to social security and taxation. An occupational disability insurance (AOV) will be introduced for the self-employed; tax advantages will be phased out (more quickly); and possibly a mandatory pension (still to be worked out).
  2. Creating more clarity on the question of when work is performed under that authority relationship as an employee, versus as a self-employed person outside employment. The government also wants to support people in asserting their legal position as an employee in cases of false self-employment. Again, we of course hope that the self-employment web module continues to be used in this, because simply by answering questions a determination is produced. So one can obtain certainty in advance, provided the answers given are truthful.
  3. Adjustment of the concept of “authority”. In clarifying the rules around assessing the working relationship, it does hold that standards within employment law (civil law) will always retain a certain openness. This is also desirable — after all, not every situation can be foreseen by the legislature, and rules need to be able to move with the dynamic practice of the labour market. The grey area can be narrowed somewhat by that self-employment web module, but more use will therefore mainly be made of legal presumptions. It remains to be seen what those legal presumptions will turn out to be. Think, for example, of rates. Self-employed workers working for rates below €35 will then be presumed to be employees unless the client can demonstrate otherwise.

 

Separate statutory scheme for self-employed workers based on the Belgian model?

On 15 September 2022, the House of Representatives again discussed the labour market, during which a senior manager from Van Havermaet in Hasselt (Belgium) gave House factions more information, via a lunch meeting, about Belgian self-employment regulations and the opportunities this offers for the Netherlands. Minister Van Gennip has indicated that she wants to draw inspiration from the Belgian model. Belgium has an Employment Relations Act in which the position of self-employed workers is laid down by law.

Belgium has neutral, general criteria that apply to every self-employed worker, and in a number of sectors there are additional specific sectoral criteria. This concerns construction, security, transport, haulage, agriculture and cleaning.

This kind of dedicated statutory scheme could perhaps offer far more clarity than the endless search for a single formula for the authority criterion.

The Belgian approach with its own scheme will, in any case, make it possible to launch enforcement against false self-employment more quickly and in a more targeted way.

Solution:

Review your self-employed contractor base before the new government plans are introduced, or before your workload actually decreases due to an economic downturn. Have this tested for false self-employment, and seek advice on the necessary adjustments to your working methods and contracts, or on terminating the engagement of your self-employed workers. This is to prevent, as far as possible, tax claims and claims of false self-employment.

 

More information?

Sign up for the masterclass ‘Managing the legal risks of your flexible workforce (flex workers and self-employed workers)’ on 23 March 2023, in which corporate lawyers Hella Vercammen and Marit Mulder explain the basic rules of the game and what to watch out for when drafting and complying with the various flex-worker and self-employed contracts. This will allow your company to make optimal and safe use of the right flexible workers. This is based on recent legislation, the government’s new plans for self-employed workers, and case law. For more information and to register: click here.

De afgelopen jaren stonden in het teken van de Wet VBAR, het wetsvoorstel dat een einde moest maken aan onduidelijkheid over de zzp’er. Het kabinet heeft delen van dat voorstel inmiddels geschrapt. Op het eerste gezicht is dat goed nieuws: minder regels, minder administratieve last. Maar in de praktijk blijven dezelfde toetsen overeind.

“De inhoud van de samenwerking is leidend, niet wat er op papier staat.”

De Belastingdienst handhaaft sinds 1 januari 2025 weer actief op schijnzelfstandigheid. En recente uitspraken van de Hoge Raad bevestigen dat rechters strikt toetsen of er sprake is van ondergeschiktheid en gezagsverhouding.

Voor uw praktijk betekent dit drie dingen. Een: leg de samenwerking duidelijk vast, met aandacht voor de inhoud. Twee: voorkom dat een zzp’er feitelijk werkt als werknemer. Drie: wees voorbereid op een controle, en weet hoe u de relatie kunt herzien als dat moet.

Heeft u vragen over uw concrete situatie? Wij sparren dagelijks met opdrachtgevers over hun zzp-relaties. Vraag een offerte op of bekijk onze Legal Safe abonnementen.

Hella Vercammen LL.M.
Bente Brouwer LL.M.
Niels Terlouw LL.M.
Puck de Jong LL.M.

Read more